Mugshot Removal Is Now a Class Issue

June 9, 2025

Mugshot removal isn’t just a privacy concern—it’s become a question of class. As online mugshots and arrest records stay highly visible through search engines and mugshot websites, individuals with fewer resources experience greater harm.

While people with financial means can afford legal help or a professional mugshot removal service, many others remain unable to do so. They are often unable to remove images and outdated arrest details published online—information that continues to hurt their chances at employment, housing, and even personal relationships.

What Is Mugshot Removal?

Mugshot removal means getting your mugshot image and related arrest record taken off mugshot sites, search engine results, and online arrest records databases. These photos are typically taken from public records and posted online, often without any accompanying legal context or outcome. A person’s mugshot can appear in Google search results even if charges are dropped or expunged.

Websites like Mugshots.com and Busted Newspaper continue to display outdated or incorrect information. They rarely check whether someone was convicted or cleared. Once your mugshot appears online, it can be disseminated across multiple websites, news sources, and other search engines. Getting your mugshot removed quickly becomes urgent if you want to protect your online reputation.

These mugshot removal websites profit from the problem they help create. They often charge steep fees to remove mugshots that arguably should never have been published in the first place. Although they claim to offer public record access, they rarely acknowledge the real-world damage they cause.

The Mugshot Removal Process: Who Can Afford It?

Removing mugshots from the internet involves several steps. People must submit a written request to the site owner or registered agent, send a formal demand letter stating their legal rights, or hire a content removal expert to manage the process. In some cases, legal action becomes necessary, especially if the site demands high fees or refuses to cooperate.

Most mugshot removal services charge between $500 and $1,500 per image. For many people, these costs are too high. But those with the means can easily pay for a removal service, send registered mail, or hire a lawyer with reasonable attorney fees to remove arrest details from Google and other search results.

Some people have their mugshots removed within days. Others face months or even years of delays, trying to reach unresponsive site owners. The process is even more complicated for those without legal knowledge, internet access, or time to follow up.

In this way, mugshot removal has become a luxury. Only those who can afford it can fully reclaim their online identity.

The Real-World Impact of Online Mugshots

When a mugshot is posted online, it can ruin lives. Even if the case is dismissed or sealed, that single booking photo can block someone from getting a job, securing housing, or moving on from their past. Employers routinely search candidates’ names and find arrest information that is either outdated or flat-out wrong.

A mugshot online acts like a permanent stain. The damage goes beyond court outcomes. Even if no crime was committed, the mugshot remains visible through Google searches and other platforms. These images often rank high in search engine results, even when more accurate or current information is available.

Although mugshots are public records, many websites publish and profit from them. They turn people’s lowest moments into long-term reputational harm. When removing mugshots depends on your ability to pay, the justice system favors the wealthy and leaves others behind. In effect, the digital world punishes people twice.

Disproportionate Harm to Low-Income Individuals

This system disproportionately affects low-income individuals the most. They are more likely to:

• Not knowing that their mugshot is visible in Google results
• Unable to pay for a mugshot removal service
• Continue to suffer from incorrect or outdated arrest records
• Be over-policed and therefore more likely to appear in mugshot databases

As a result, many individuals become stuck in a cycle of lost opportunities. Employers, landlords, and even schools may judge them based on old or misleading information.

Sarah, a single mom in Georgia, was never convicted of a crime. However, her mugshot was posted online and subsequently copied across multiple websites. She applied for jobs but was rejected again and again. She couldn’t afford to remove the mugshot, and that cost her more than money. It cost her security and peace of mind.

This scenario is common. Many people are unaware that their mugshot is online until an employer or landlord brings it up. The shock and shame can be overwhelming. The damage extends far beyond the screen.

Laws and Loopholes: A Patchwork System

State laws on mugshot removal vary wildly. Florida law allows individuals to request the removal of their mugshots in certain instances, particularly when no conviction has been recorded. In California, legal action has helped push back against some mugshot websites. But serious loopholes still exist.

Some websites are hosted overseas or utilize complex ownership structures to evade accountability. Others only respond to removal requests if they receive a legal threat. In many cases, the sites ignore requests until forced by court orders or state law.

Even in states like Alabama and Kentucky, where lawmakers are trying to address the issue, the rules remain confusing. Some states have no process at all. And because search engines like Google operate independently, even when a mugshot is removed from a site, it may still appear in search results.

Solutions That Level the Playing Field

To make mugshot removal fairer, several things need to change:

1. Stronger State Laws
States must require the removal of mugshots when someone is cleared or never charged. These laws should prevent websites from charging high removal fees and limit the duration for which mugshots can remain online. Requiring links to court outcomes would also add necessary context.

2. More Affordable Legal Help
People who can’t pay for a private removal service need access to legal aid. State and local governments should support nonprofit legal clinics. These clinics can offer free consultations, help draft demand letters, and explain people’s rights.

3. Better Oversight of Search Engines
Google and other platforms must update their policies. Mugshots should not appear in top search results if they relate to cases that were dropped or resolved. Public pressure and legal reform can encourage these companies to prioritize the removal of harmful or outdated content.

4. Free or Subsidized Removal Services
Government agencies or nonprofits could offer content removal services at no cost or a reduced rate. These services would help people navigate takedown requests, contact site owners, and pursue legal steps where needed. This would go a long way in closing the class gap.

Final Thoughts: This Is About More Than Privacy

Mugshot removal isn’t just about your image or reputation—it’s about fairness. When only people with money can remove their mugshot from the internet, we create a system that punishes the poor twice.

A mugshot taken in a moment of fear or confusion shouldn’t follow someone for life. Yet that’s precisely what happens to thousands of people every year. Until we fix this broken system, mugshot removal will stay a class issue.

It’s time for change.

Free Mugshot Removal Analysis